The editing was horrible. It is WAY over edited, the viewer can never tell whats going on. These days montages seem to be more about fancy editing as opposed to quality gameplay.

really good

I`m not sure I`d agree that the gameplay was ``terrible``. It could be a lot better, sure, but not terrible. Anyways, thank you for the in-depth review TheMontageCritic. Glad someone took the time to make a little write up :)

good editing and music, gameplay = terrible

Ok as my first Halo 3 montage to criticize I have to say that it was a pretty good montage. There was some good editing that kept you in the video and there wasn`t to much of it.The music was great, it kept you wanting more of it because it wasn`t to hard but definitly not to soft and when it was slow the montage went right with it.The clips.......some were amazing but some were kinda dull. For the most part the clips were really fast-paced but there were a couple that really didn`t need to be in there or that could have been replaced.After all of this being said I am going to give this montage an overall score of 8 out of 10. TheMontageCritic